Good Craft Is Not Enough
I enjoy a mosaic that is beautifully made. A clean cut, a confident line of tesserae or an unexpected way of using glass can stop me in my tracks. I know the work behind those choices. But I have also admired the workmanship in a mosaic and found myself ready to move on. Another, with less tidy cutting, may keep me looking. That difference matters to me.
Think about making water. You could use neat, even rows. They might suggest a quiet current, or they might make the stream look like a strip of blue glass. Change the direction of a few pieces, vary the gaps, introduce small flashes of light, and the water might begin to move. Or it might turn into a distraction. The workmanship alone does not tell us which result is better.
This is one reason I like working in mosaic. We do not just place colors where an image says they belong. We choose the size, shape, direction, edge and spacing of every piece. Those choices change the image, sometimes in ways I only notice after stepping back.
Take my Brookside. In the lower part of the mosaic, dark, nearly horizontal passages give the stream its course. Pale blue and violet glints break up the darkness. Above the water, the glass turns into slimmer, angled greens and yellows. Then there is a warm orange-yellow area toward the right that draws the eye. The subject is a stream and its surroundings, but those glass decisions help determine how we see it.
What interests me is not whether I cut those pieces neatly. It is whether the water still reads beneath the brighter growth. Do the little glints suggest reflected light or just scattered light spots? Does the warm patch invite the eye into the scene, or pull it away from the water? My answers may change with the distance and the light. That is worth finding out.
When I am unsure about a passage, I try to make the problem visible before I change anything. I step back. I look under different light. Sometimes I cover a few pieces to see what happens to the larger image. I also like asking another artist what catches their eye. If we notice different things, that gives us something to look at together, not a winner and a loser.
Of course, an artist can get exactly the effect they intended and still make an uninteresting work. And an accident can become the best part. I look at what the whole mosaic offers: where it leads me, what it makes clear, what it leaves open, how the materials contribute and whether I want to return to it. I can usually explain why one passage works better than another. Sometimes I change my mind. Good judgment needs room for that.
None of this is an argument against skill. The more we can do with glass, the more choices we have. But a perfect cut is not always the right cut. Sometimes the awkward piece that bothers us at the bench gives the image just what it needs across the room.
So before you replace a piece because it looks imperfect, walk away and look at the whole mosaic. See what it is doing. You may decide to fix it. You may decide to leave it alone. Either choice will be better informed.

Comments